Why water-filled dominates the market
For long runs along a river or around a construction dewatering site, water is free, plentiful and right there. Mass is the cheapest way to resist a head of water, and a water-filled tube gets its mass for nothing. Dam-It Dams, AquaDam and Aqua-Barrier all built their businesses on this and it is the right answer for those jobs.
Where water-filled stops working
A shop doorway in a flooding street. An underground garage ramp. A basement plant room. A site where the flood has not arrived yet and there is no water to pump. In every one of these the water-filled barrier's advantage becomes its constraint — you cannot fill it until the thing you are defending against arrives.
This is the case air-filled exists for, and it is a real one.
The honest limit on air-filled
Water pressure against a barrier rises with the square of height. Air-filled units resist that through anchoring rather than mass, so anchoring quality and ground condition matter enormously, and there is a height beyond which the approach stops being sensible.
We will not quote a height without structural data behind it. Anyone who does is guessing with your site.